The Apocalypse Is Coming

Sunday, October 25, 2026

Title: The Apocalypse Is Coming

Service Leader: Rev. Eric Banner

Worship Associate: Cynthia Phinney

Music Team: First Universalist Band

NOTE: This text is pulled directly from our Worship Team’s sermon notes and may differ slightly from the message delivered on Sunday. Click the "Watch Here" button to watch a recorded livestream of the service.

Sermon: The Apocalypse Is Coming – Rev. Eric Banner

I found that reading from Maya Angelou in our gray hymnals while planning for this service, and it felt like such a fitting way to step off in this second in our series of once a month services about relationship skills we all need, but so many of us need reminding of, or never learned in the first place. If you look for commentary on the poem, it comes across as a sort of criticism of love, a dissatisfaction with it, every new love destined to end, and end badly. And I hear that, but I think it misses the cyclical nature of our lives.

This is one of those themes I return to, again and again, the way that how we view our lives, as a line from point A to point Z, or as a series of ever expanding circles, matters immensely. If we “begin to stop, in order simply to begin again,” then it means that there is good news. That we can approach things and try to do better when we know better, as Angelou said once in an interview. We are not just restricted to being stuck in the past, but are gifted the opportunity to build a better and brighter day, beginning again in love, with a foundation that is strengthened with each new addition our lives, and our choices, add to them.

So this month, I wanted to share some learnings about conflicts that have meant a lot to me. They come from a pair of researchers, Julie & John Gottman, and have been central to their work and workshops that, in spite of the name are not actually Unitarian Universalist. The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work are not in any way connected to the UU Seven Principles that so many of us know. The Gottmans are Jewish. Their work is decidedly secular and rooted in decades of research the likes of which marriage and family therapy had never known before them.

Sensors and fully furnished apartments turned into research labs. Multi-decade studies following the same couples. But it’s also true that what they have found feels relevant to so much more than just romantic couples. It feels relevant to us all, because we come to places like this and we say we want to build community and connections, but eventually, sooner or later, all of us are going to end up in a conversation or a project where someone is going to rub us the wrong way. And in that moment, and in the moments of repair afterwards, we’re offered a choice of how we will ground our own hopes and desires and our own identity to make repair most possible.

Just a couple of months ago Priya Parker, whom I’ve mentioned from this pulpit before, put out a new book that I’ve started but not yet finished, titled “The Art of Fighting.” In it she explores the question of “How do you fight with those to whom you want to belong?”

And that is why I bring the Gottmans to us this week, because they have asked that very question about the most challenging relationships we have, because they have the highest stakes, and the greatest expectations, but the basics remain the same no matter where it is we want to belong.
So let me start with the bad news. The solution is not to never have fights. To never have conflicts. It’s just not viable if you want to have a relationship, if you want to have community, if you want to belong.

In fact, in the category of statistics I absolutely hate, and want to fight against, over decades of research Julie & John Gottman have found that in successfully married couples 69% of all their conflicts are simply unsolveable. They have found that these conflicts, rooted in personality and preferences, are perpetual. That when you got together you chose which 69% of conflicts you would live with, and had you chosen someone else, you wouldn’t have fewer conflicts, you would just have a different set of them. I hate that statistic. I want it to be different. I want to believe that with dedication and hard work and good communication we could drop the number of them by at least a little bit. But hidden within it is the good news I want to share today.

It's not being in conflict that’s the problem. It’s that there are specific things you can do, or not do, that change the likelyhood of a conflict become a toxic cesspool that brings things to a bitter end.

More than anything else, their research has found that the presence of what they have come to call the four horsemen of the relationship apocalypse, I promise, I was going to get the sermon title eventually, predict with more than 90% accuracy, whether a relationship will crash or last. The word apocalypse, by the way, is from an ancient Greek word, most well known from the last chapter of the Bible, and is best translated as a revelation, an unveiling of hidden knowledge. But in this case, what they mean is the destruction that is analogous to the four horsemen that personify destruction.

So what are they? Criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling.

I bet none of that suprises you. In fact, I’m willing to bet that every person in this room has been on the giving and receiving end of every one of those experiences. Maybe even this week.
But, again and again, in their research the Gottmans found that when these behaviors became entrenched, they colored everything else about the relationship, and prevented the work of connection and repair that are the bones of lifelong friendship and joy.

Some weeks I’m here encouraging you to do certain things, but this week, my encouragement to all of us is to notice what we do not want to do. To notice when we fall into the traps of these four horsemen, because the data suggests we all will, but we can recognize them and we can do better the next time.

Criticism may be the most common of them, but in many ways it is the trickiest. When we’re in conflict with someone, a friend, a fellow church member, a parent, a partner, it almost always helps to be able to be specific about what happened that is causing the problem. But saying things like (Note: examples drawn directly from HERE):

“You never clean up after yourself. You’re so lazy.”

Or

“You’re always late. You have no respect for anyone else’s time.”

Or

“You’re terrible with money. Why are you so irresponsible?”

Which all start with that verbal finger pointing of “you” and follow it with character judgements like lazy, disrespectful, irresponsible, we can all work to ground the conversation in the thing that no reasonable person can argue with, our own experience and our own requests.

“The messy kitchen is stressing me out. Could you help me clean it up?”

 

“I get anxious when we’re running late. Could we start getting ready earlier next time?”

 

“I’m feeling anxious about our budget. Can we look over it together?”

We can hear the difference. The way that we identify the thing that’s connected to our own subjective experience, and then we look for partnership in making a change. It’s a technique that, over the years, they’ve come to call the softened start up.

Sure, we can point the finger, and talk about what an awful person someone is, but who is going to respond well to that. And, just like last month, when we explored nonviolent communication, using that softened startup as tool, helps us identify our own feelings in advance, instead of telling someone that we care about that they are fundamentally broken, and they need to get their act together, because they are always doing things wrong.

And, yes, if you’re wondering, the softened startup is the part I struggle with the most. Why, I want to ask, can’t we just get straight to the problem? Why can’t we just talk about what you did wrong? Wouldn’t that be delightfully efficient? And the answer turns out to be that if you ever want to get to the problem, you’ve got to identify the thing that really matters in any relationship, how the situation made you feel.

But wait, as the old television infomercials used to say, there’s more. Have you ever heard someone say to you:

Oh, please…

 

Are you serious?

 

You’re ridiculous…

 

Of course you would…

 

How hard is it to…

Those are signs, too. Signs of contempt, which is the second horseman of the relationship apocalypse. It comes in spoken and unspoken forms, the “Sneering, eye-rolling, hostile sarcasm, or talking down to the other person” that says you see a hierarchy between you and the person you’re speaking with, and both of you know who is one up and who is one down. And it’s important to recognize that sometimes you are in situations where you are one up and one down. You might be an employee with a boss who is setting an expectation, who is laying out a consequence of a behavior or a project that went wrong, but even then, the work of avoiding contempt is the work of avoiding the sense that it is personal. When we say we believe in the inherent worth of everyone, we’re saying that we’re all in this together.

And sometimes we also need to say something more. That there is a rule, or a guideline, or a value that calls us all to account, and we can return, over and again, to the shared agreements we have, so that the conversation isn’t fueled long simmering disagreements, but instead is grounded in an invitation to the recognition that we could all stand to do a little better. And in your personal relationships, hierarchy is deadly. “Who does he think he is? Why does he think he’s so much better than the rest of us?”

Contempt serves no one.

There’s two more horsemen, and not nearly enough time. It’s the trouble with sermonizing from hundreds of pages of material. But they are the two that feel easiest to identify, and with the easiest antidotes. Defensiveness and stonewalling. I’ll never forget working in this little coffee shop when I was a teenager, the youngest employee there by a long shot, and the owner, who had been explicitly trained that criticism was management, would come in and always have something negative to say.

I wanted, truly wanted, to be better, but in the face of that force of nature, what I did instead was to talk about my intent, my effort, what I had done and was doing. I was defensive, and that was what I was told. What I needed was the ability to quiet the voices in my own head, and listen.

John Gottman says defensiveness is his greatest weakness. And over the years he’s had to learn what to do with it. So now he carries a decidedly low tech solution. A notepad in his back pocket. It’s his method to self-regulate, to down-regulate what feels like a threat, and to approach it with the curiosity that the Buddhists might call the calm mind. The answer, in Buddhism, and in life, is to insert the pause that keeps you from responding right away.

And then you say “I'm listening. I really want to understand what you're saying. I'm going to take notes. I may have to slow you down a little bit, but I want to hear what you have to say. And then I'm going to check out and make sure I got it, that I understand what you're saying. And I'm going to try to really empathize with your emotions. I want to try to really understand how you feel. And in that way, you … downregulate defensiveness.”

The problem with being on the receiving end of someone else’s feelings, is that for many of us, especially for men, it’s easy to experience it as hierarchy, to feel it as overwhelming, to feel it as if it’s something that has to be dealt with RIGHT NOW, and our entire system is wired to fight, or flee, or fawn, or freeze. And freezing has another name when it happens in our relationships, it’s stonewalling. We shut down, and Gottman's research suggests that this is so characteristically male that 85% of the time it’s a man who stonewalls the conversation. We leave. We turn on the TV. We look at our phone. We do anything to avoid recognizing that when we have the chance to self-regulate, we can then return to a conversation and make something productive of it. It doesn’t have to be right now. We can schedule a conversation. We can name our own experience, and honor the experience of the people we love, and it doesn’t have to be either or. “I’d like to take a walk first. I hear how important this is to you, and that makes it important to me, too, but I’m feeling overwhelmed and I want to give you the care and attention that this deserves.”

This work of being a human is the work of being able to connect with one another in the ways that matter to us most, knowing we will fail, knowing we will fall short, and trying still to do better, again and again and again. Or, as Maya Angelou put it, to –

“begin to stop, in order simply to begin again.”

We’re not perfect. We will make mistakes. We will have to find ways to repair the damage we’ve done. To listen. To understand. To give and to receive. But if we want to be able to keep solving the solvable problems, if we want to find the space for a joyful acceptance of the foibles of the ones we love, and trust that they will give us back the same in return, then the first step is just knowing what to avoid doing, and from there build up the foundation that will hold, the boat that will carry, the trust that says you can count on me like 1, 2, 3. And when we need it, we can count on you like four, three, two and you'll be there, ready to hold the heart of our highest hopes, our greatest fears, our biggest disappointments, and all that is our life.

Rev. Eric Banner
Senior Minister